Menu of Ben and Scooter's Hanover in Hanover, Pennsylvania, USA

Menu Overview

Ben and Scooter's Hanover is a charming ice cream shop nestled at 1767 Baltimore Pike, Hanover, PA, known for its warm hospitality and quality treats. This cozy spot stands out not just for its friendly owners but also for a thoughtfully crafted menu that caters to classic and creative palates alike.

One cannot talk about Ben and Scooter's without highlighting their signature Watermelon Snow Ball, a refreshing and unique twist that perfectly captures the essence of summer in each bite. Equally impressive is the Churro, which delivers a satisfying crunch alongside a sweet, cinnamon-rich flavor that pairs beautifully with their creamy ice cream.

The S'More Sundae is an indulgence worth savoring. Featuring toasted marshmallow, chocolate, and graham cracker elements layered with silky vanilla ice cream, it evokes nostalgia with every spoonful. This sundae is a perfect example of how the shop elevates classic desserts with a homemade touch.

Their sundae selection is diverse and rich, from the velvety Butterscotch Vanilla with butterscotch sauce and whipped cream to the tangy yet sweet Black Raspberry topping that adds a burst of flavor. The Apple Cider Float offers seasonal charm with its crisp apple cider base, vanilla ice cream, and a drizzle of caramel—comfort in a glass. Meanwhile, the Peanut Butter sundae and Wet Walnut create an inviting nutty experience that’s creamy, smooth, and satisfying.

Milkshake lovers will appreciate the freshly spun options. The Cotton Candy and Chocolate shakes are particularly delightful, with balanced sweetness and a silky texture that feels reminiscent of childhood pleasures yet executed with freshness and quality ingredients.

For those looking for a more substantial treat, the Banana Split Towers offer generous layers of flavor and texture. The Peanut Butter tower is a standout, combining rich peanut butter ice cream, chocolate sauce, and Reese's pieces for a decadent, playful dessert. Meanwhile, the Classic banana split holds true to tradition with its mix of chocolate and vanilla ice cream, tropical pineapple, strawberry, and whipped cream, making it both nostalgic and satisfying.

Customer feedback echoes this sentiment with praise for the variety, freshness, and friendly service. Visitors like Shawn Rosado and Louvennia Hardesty commend the owners’ warmth and the welcoming environment, while others highlight quick, personable staff interactions that enhance the overall experience.

Overall, Ben and Scooter's Hanover offers more than just ice cream. It promises a moment of joy, comfort, and community, wrapped in thoughtfully crafted flavors that encourage repeat visits. Whether you’re indulging in the fruit-forward Watermelon Snow Ball, diving into a creamy Peanut Butter sundae, or savoring a freshly spun Strawberry Milkshake, this ice cream shop delivers quality and character in every scoop.